In a previous post, I wrote about how I hate war as only a warrior can. Something I wrote in there, however, was overshadowed by the point I was trying to make. The part that was overshadowed: while I hate war, I loved combat. Like the paradox of the veteran story and the violence of action paradox, this is another unresolved imbalance. Many veterans feel this way: they’d go back if they could.
This is a topic that has come up recently in several discussions I’ve had. How can we hate war, hate killing, hate the psychological impact of it…but at the same time love it, long for it, crave it? I was having a conversation with a colleague a couple of weeks ago, and they asked me a question that I hadn’t considered before.
“If you could close your eyes, and in an instant, open them and be anywhere in the world for 24 hours, where would you be?”
I thought about it, briefly. I’d been to London. North Africa. I’ve been on beaches and mountaintops. As I was rolling each of these foreign and exotic places around in my mind, I realized what the truth was: I’d choose to be in the Kunar River Valley, Afghanistan. In a heartbeat, without hesitation.
It was there that the most significant times of my life were spent. Outside of the moments that surround my family, such as my wedding and the births of my children, and the spiritual moments relating to my Christian faith, the most important moments of my life occurred on the roads winding through those mountains.
As Uncle George said in the quote at the beginning of this article, sometimes things in life after the military pale in comparison to our experiences in combat. The rush, the adrenaline, the camaraderie, the skillful execution of abilities developed for just this moment.
Veterans talk about being addicted to combat. Being a mental health professional, I feel as though it’s my duty to specify that the only classified clinical mental health disorders that qualify as addictions focus on substances…alcohol, amphetamines, opiates, etc…with only the exception of gambling disorder. Other “behavioral addictions,” such as compulsive sexual behavior or compulsive exercising, are not considered “addictions” in the clinical sense.
But oh, yes, how we love it so.
The challenge with any obsession, or compulsion, or whatever you want to call it, is that it overshadows our current lives, and we tend to long for the glory days of years gone by. We forget how hard those glory days really were, and instead pine for the bygone days when we were younger, stronger, slimmer and yes, had more hair.
We become stuck in the fact that who we are is a lesser version of who we were, and we tend to walk through life backwards. Is it a form of the high school football start who never really made it big in college, and he goes back to the high school kegger in his too-small letterman jacket?
Don’t get me wrong. It’s great to reminisce. To reflect on where we’ve come from, in order to understand more about where we are and give direction to where we’re going. But to long for the good old days? To chase the rush and play the same song in order to capture lightening in the bottle just one more time? We are farther along on our life path than we were then. We cannot step into the same river twice.
I tell veterans all the time: we are now and forever will be veterans. I can’t go back and be the “old me,” the 17 year old kid that knew nothing and had less going for him. I can’t even go back and be the 25 year old me, the crazy fool full of piss and vinegar, jumping out of every aircraft he could get onto. Similarly, we can’t be something we’re not; although I no longer wear a uniform, I’m not a civilian. Because I no longer wear a uniform, I’m no longer a soldier. I’m a strange mix of the two, a thing called “veteran,” which is hard for both service members and civilians to relate to. And even more, a combat veteran, one which others who have served in the military but who have not been to combat sometimes find it hard to understand.
So a veteran wants to retreat into their past, but can’t. So some do the next best thing: retreat into their memory of the past, which is a hazy and imperfect thing. They long for the days, the horrible glorious days, where bullets flew and the smell of copper and carbon filled the air. They crave those days as much as anyone craves anything; for some, no lover, no substance, no situation can ever measure up to the dizzying heights of combat.
But it doesn’t have to be that way. Our lives did not peak on a mountaintop in Afghanistan, or a jungle in Vietnam. They do if we think they do; if we see that as the ultimate achievement in our lives, and everything else is downhill and meaningless, then that’s what we will believe. That’s not the case.
If you find yourself stuck here, then reach out. Find a counselor or a therapist that understands what you’re going through, and sit down and talk.
You might find that the best days of your life are truly in front of you, not behind.
France, Duane. "The Combat Addiction Paradox." Head Space and Timing, 21 Feb. 2017.
Please remember, we are not able to give medical or legal advice. If you have medical concerns, please consult your doctor. All posted comments are the views and opinions of the poster only.
Anonymous replied on Permalink
My wife and I have a dear friend who served in a very specialized combat unit. What little I know I cannot share. This man and his wife have been married forever; she’s devoted to him, and I’m certain he is to her. But he’s stuck. Chasing what he did in combat and finding ways to continue. If he doesn’t, he drinks. Way too much. He needs help badly, but I can’t talk to him. I didn’t serve. My father was Navy, and I intended to fly F-4s. Didn’t work out. The point is I have no credibility in his world. So how do I help?
Mike M. replied on Permalink
I am a disabled combat Veteran and I too long for the "glory" days from time to time. When I first left the military I constantly contemplated returning back to duty. I had one and only one combat tour in Afghanistan and it left me bitter, angry, and unsatisfied, as if my efforts weren't enough. it has been four years now since I left the service. I went through mental health counseling and mental health hospital stays.
I had a place to stay, with my dad and then my mom and I was working on my college degree at a local community college using the G.I. bill. I found it very difficult to stay in class trying to learn while listening to anti military college students and teachers. I had to sit in the back of the classroom incase of a shooter or bomber and I paid more attention to backpacks people had and what could possibly be in them, a gun, a bomb?
My girlfriend at the time mentioned a local online college and I tried it out. From the first semester I found it easier to learn and pass my classes. I eventually moved out into my own apartment with my girlfriend and continued to work on online courses. I would constantly have nightmares, some of the combat and some others. I had difficult times falling asleep, hypervigilant and aggressive.
Some time has passed now and I have earned my Associates Degree in Business Systems and I am now working on my Bachelors in Business Systems Management. I purchased my first home and married my girlfriend who stuck with me through all of my transitioning. I have improved on my sleep, attitude, anxiety and aggression. If I can break it down into how I have improved to live a quality life, I would contribute that to having a good family support system, mental health counseling, and VA support. I am no longer bitter, angry, or unsatisfied of my efforts and contributions during my deployment and I hold my head high knowing I did my best. That time will always remain a crucial key in my life that allowed me to grow into the man I am today and reassure me that if I can survive that I can do wonders with what time I have left.
You have to keep pushing forward, inch by inch, day by day never giving up and eyes ahead, leading by example. What we have done in the past is all good and well, but, what can you do today to improve?
Rosemary replied on Permalink
Such depth here. This line really stood out to me: although I no longer wear a uniform, I’m not a civilian. Because I no longer wear a uniform, I’m no longer a soldier. I’m a strange mix of the two, a thing called “veteran,” which is hard for both service members and civilians to relate to. Beautifully written and expressed.