In a microsecond, out of the blue, comes a trauma that changes our life forever.
[♪♪] [sportscaster announcing game]
[D. McMillon] Hard knocks can come with serious consequences.
Find out more about the effects of concussion and how they can be treated,
next on BrainLine.
[♪upbeat music♪] [brainline.org]
[Concussion: Understanding Mild Traumatic Brain Injury]
[female announcer] BrainLine is funded by the Defense and Veterans Brain Injury Center,
the primary operational TBI component of the Defense Centers of Excellence,
through the Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine.
Welcome to BrainLine. I'm Doris McMillon.
This webcast is the first in a series of discussions we'll be having
about preventing, treating and living with traumatic brain injury.
Today's program looks at concussion or mild traumatic brain injury,
mild TBI for short.
Joining me are Lesley LeMasurier, a senior at the University of Colorado.
She's a former Alpine ski racer who was training with the US Ski Team
when she suffered the fifth in a series of concussions that ended her career.
Also with us is Dr. Aditya Bhagwat, a board certified clinical neuropsychologist
currently working in the Defense and Veterans Brain Injury Center
at Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Washington, DC.
Dr. Bhagwat, thanks so much for joining us. >>[Bhagwat] Thank you.
We're also very pleased to have Dr. James Kelly on our panel.
Dr. Kelly is Professor of Neurosurgery and Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
at the University of Colorado Denver School of Medicine.
He is a Fellow of the American Academy of Neurology
and has worked with many professional athletes.
I want to thank you all so much for joining us.
We'd also like to welcome our studio audience.
Each year more than 1.5 million people
experience some form of traumatic brain injury
with cases ranging from mild to severe.
Mild TBIs are also known as concussions, and that's what we're here to talk about.
Dr. Kelly, let me start with you.
Most people with a concussion--let's say about 85 percent--are fine after a few weeks.
So why is it important to talk about concussion?
Concussions really happen so commonly that still huge numbers of people have them.
Even if only 15 percent have lingering symptoms,
that's still a huge number of people in this country and worldwide.
And so the concern we have is some may be glossed over or misunderstood,
and if we can apply treatments relatively early,
even those people can have improved outcomes or recover more quickly.
[McMillon] All right.
Exactly what is a concussion or mild TBI?
A concussion is at the mild end of the spectrum of traumatic brain injury
in which perhaps an individual has a biomechanical injury,
a blow to the head or a whiplash type mechanism injury,
and they may or may not be rendered unconscious,
meaning coma for a very short span of time.
But they may have a stunning blow, be confused or something at the time
or have a gap in their memory.
And that is reflecting brain dysfunction.
It's a biomechanical effect on the brain tissue itself
that sets in motion a series of changes in the nerve cells themselves
that cause disruption of function.
Okay, so what really happens to the brain?
A series of things happen.
The force itself actually shakes the brain inside the skull.
A wave propagates mechanically through the brain tissue
and sets off an irritation that actually causes a discharge of chemicals,
an electrical discharge across the cortex.
There can also be, if the force is great enough,
biomechanical damage that shears the nerve cells.
It doesn't do it necessarily instantaneously,
but the cells themselves swell, especially the part called the axon.
And so there can be microscopic damage that we can't see on scans
that actually affects the anatomy and the function of the brain cells.
Okay. So is it fair to say that that's what's happening neurologically?
[Kelly] Yes. >>Okay.
How can I tell if I've had a concussion? Do I have to lose consciousness?
No. It's absolutely not the case that one needs to lose consciousness.
And the individual who has had the injury may assume that they've lost consciousness
because they can't account for some span of time.
That's really memory gap. That's amnesia. That's not necessarily unconsciousness.
So if, in fact, somebody can't account for some span of time
or there's a span of time even that they feel foggy
and they can't really track what's going on, even without unconsciousness
that can be a concussion.
So what are some of the other signs of mild TBI?
Right off the bat, the signs that people would exhibit
would be often in coordination or they would look confused.
If we were to do mental status testing right there as we do with athletes on the field,
we can tell that they're not making sense, they can't track what's going on
or they have memory problems.
Separately then are the symptoms that an individual would express
if they're able to tell you.
They have a headache, they'll feel dizzy, nauseated and so forth.
So if somebody says after sustaining some kind of trauma,
"How many fingers do I have?" we laugh about that, but that's for real, isn't it?
[Kelly] That's a good example because that is used often,
but it's not a very good test of whether someone's had a concussion or not.
A much better test would be to ask them to remember something
and ask them a minute or two or three later,
"What was it that you were asked to remember?"
If they can't remember something like that, they're in amnesia
or they're not processing information properly.
[McMillon] Let's talk about the confusion and then the nausea.
Can you expand on that a little bit more?
When we're looking at what is the threshold of injury,
did somebody really have a traumatic brain injury or not,
you need to decide what's the threshold.
So if somebody actually has a span of time of confusion
where they're not making sense or they're walking in the wrong direction
or something after a blow to the head from whatever cause,
that may represent confusion right there at the time,
and that's the outward sign that you're really seeing,
and that may be all there is at the time.
How long does that confusion last?
For most people, it's transient. It's momentary.
It can be seconds, minutes, it can go on for hours,
but that usually bridges to more serious injury and other signs that evolve with time.
[McMillon] What about the nausea?
Nausea, we think, is partly due to the swelling of the brain
and the release of neurochemicals with the injury itself
that actually cause that experience internally for the person.
And I know we're talking about light headaches.
There's headaches that can be quite intense right at the time
and, in fact, headaches, whenever we survey individuals who have had concussions,
that tops the list of what they experience.
Many other things are part of the picture of the syndrome, if you will, of concussion,
but headache seems to be the common denominator,
the thing that really tops the list in civilian and sports and military experience
when somebody has had a concussion.
What about mood changes? Is that something that you see?
Yes. Mood changes can occur acutely during that confusional state.
Sometimes big, strapping athletes will be crying
or be so mixed up in their confusional state
that they can't make sense of what's really happening at the time
and so they look bewildered and have a whole variety, a range of emotions.
More commonly, down the road there is a kind of a sadness,
a creeping sense days and weeks later if the symptoms persist,
that can truly be depression.
And so there are mood elements that have to do with the dysfunction of the brain,
and there are also reactions to the dysfunction of the brain,
and those become merged in terms of mood issues down the road.
Do they go away?
For some people they go away spontaneously. For others they need help.
They need help both in terms of counseling and in terms of medications.
Okay. What are some of the most common causes of traumatic brain injury?
Causes in the civilian world typically have been historically motor vehicle collisions
here in the United States, and that still is high on the list.
But now with increased data gathering, we're actually seeing that falls
has crept up to be a serious problem, and that occurs in two age groups--
in toddlers who are learning to walk
and in the elderly who are beginning to have balance and coordination problems.
[McMillon] So either end of the spectrum. >>Either end of the age life cycle.
I think when we talked earlier you mentioned young men between a certain age.
The other peak incidence then is between 15 and 25
and more men than women, males than females in that age group
who are more risk-taking, engaged in various activities
that have to do with outdoor sports or various other kinds of things
that run the risk of traumatic brain injury.
And so there is that age group in which the behavior itself
and linked to motor vehicle collisions is really a significant incidence.
Okay. Dr. Bhagwat, let me come to you.
Let's take a step back briefly and then talk about the full range of traumatic brain injury
from mild to moderate to severe.
What's been the impact of TBI in the military since the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan?
It's had a pretty large impact.
Numbers now are around 20 percent of soldiers or of servicemembers
have suffered some type of traumatic brain injury
anywhere on the spectrum from mild to severe.
It's also raised awareness of TBI in the military in general
so that actually we're better at tracking them and spotting them as well.
What's the difference between concussion, which Dr. Kelly talked about,
and then some of the moderate to severe TBI cases that you see?
Actually, the majority of what we see, even coming back, are mild concussions,
but they run the spectrum from mild to severe.
The moderate and severe are really a different animal
from the concussion we're talking about.
They're often more severe loss of consciousness,
more severe alteration of consciousness like Dr. Kelly was talking about.
You can see findings on imaging much more often, contusions or bleeds
such as hemorrhages in the brain.
They are more symptomatic at the time, and recovery can take longer as well.
What are some of the causes of those TBIs,
and are the causes the same for mild TBIs?
It depends on the TBI, the type you're talking about.
It can be a matter of severity.
Like in a car accident or an MVA in theater,
someone could have a mild injury from that or a severe injury.
But some of the more moderate and severe injuries we see
are more from penetrating injuries as well such as shrapnel
from an improvised explosive device exploding or gunshot wounds to the head.
[McMillon] Okay. Anything else?
You see also the falls and you see motor vehicle accidents.
You can have other just combat-related injuries.
[McMillon] What might some of those injuries be?
If there are explosions nearby, like the blast injuries that we've talked about,
there are primary blast injuries.
Even just being near a large explosion can cause an injury.
[McMillon] Okay. The IEDs? >>IEDs. >>[McMillon] Okay. All right.
Is there a neurological difference between a concussion
that a football player might sustain from a collision
compared to the concussion that a soldier sustains when a bomb is exploding?
That's a great question, and the answer is maybe.
That's where a lot of research is going into right now,
to finding the effects of what we call the primary blast injury,
which is just the force of the blast itself, the wave coming off the blast.
A lot of the folks that we see also have secondary and tertiary injuries,
which means the shrapnel injuries, things flying from the explosion and striking them
or the individual being thrown into something.
I recently interviewed a soldier who had an RPG explode near him...
[McMillon] An RPG? >>A rocket-propelled grenade.
[McMillon] Okay. >>...where he was thrown against a wall,
which caused him to lose consciousness.
[McMillon] Oh, my goodness. Okay. Are the symptoms the same?
They are similar. They're very similar.
Like Dr. Kelly was saying, headaches are one of the number one symptoms.
We have vertigo and dizziness problems, the nausea,
some of the photo and phonophobia, sensitivity to light and noise.
[McMillon] Do you see the mood changes as well? >>We see the mood changes as well.
And, of course, in our population they've also been through very many traumatic experiences
so there's that overlay as well.
Okay. What's the military currently doing to try to identify people
who might have sustained a mild TBI?
There's a very strong program actually for identifying TBI now,
not only in the wounded that actually come to the hospitals,
but all returning soldiers that come back get screened one way or another.
Oftentimes it's by their physicians, or they also have to fill out a questionnaire
that asks about symptoms.
And anyone who is reporting symptoms that might be due to a TBI
will get referred for a full evaluation.
Okay, so once you find them, then tell us how the diagnosis works.
The diagnosis for us is based on mechanism of injury
and what the symptoms were during the injury such as loss of consciousness,
alteration of consciousness.
Cognitive and neuropsych testing are a piece of that as well,
but it's really based on the interview and medical records that go into it
because while neuropsych testing is very efficient and it's very good at finding,
it's very sensitive to brain dysfunction, it's not very specific necessarily.
So if you test someone and they have deficits on testing,
that doesn't automatically mean they had a brain injury.
There are other factors that could be affecting testing as well.
So the interview is very important.
And generally what are you finding out in the interview?
We talk to the soldier or servicemember and try to find out from them
what they remember of the actual incident.
We can also use collateral information from people that were in their unit
that have come back that might have seen the person.
And like Dr. Kelly was saying, they might not remember what happened to them,
but we get reports from others that can tell us what happened.
[McMillon] All right. Dr. Bhagwat, thank you so much.
In just a moment we're going to talk to Lesley LeMasurier
about her experience as an Alpine ski racer,
but first a report on sports and mild traumatic brain injury.
Garrick Utley is reporting, and you might recognize Dr. Kelly.
He worked with the hockey player in our story. Let's take a look.
[Utley] Head injuries can happen to anyone,
but thrill seekers like Randall Chestnut are most at risk.
He's always loved extreme sports--skiing, rock climbing and, above all, mountain biking.
When you're screaming downhill on a bumpy, muddy course
it's hard to let the daily troubles of the world stay in your mind.
[Utley] It's young adults who sustain brain injuries most frequently.
They drive too fast, play too hard, take too many risks.
I'm not sure it's the risk that's the appeal of sports that some people would call extreme.
I think it's the challenge.
[Utley] But when we met Chestnut at this hospital in Portland, Oregon,
it wasn't because he'd injured his head, though he did break his neck once while rock climbing.
It's because Dr. Chestnut is Director of Neurotrauma here
and one of the top neurosurgeons in the country.
Traumatic brain injury is the leading cause of death
in patients between 15 and 45, in the most productive years of their lives.
For those who survive, a brain injury can undermine everything that makes us human--
our ability to think, to learn, to remember and to relate to the people we love.
He looks at first like any other dad teaching his 3-year-old son how to skate.
[male speaker] All right. You have to skate over to Daddy.
[Utley] But this father in Greenwich, Connecticut, knows his way around the ice.
Good job! All right, here we go.
[Utley] It's Pat LaFontaine, who might be the best American-born hockey player ever.
[sportscaster] LaFontaine moving in, fights off the check, and he scores!
[Utley] He played 14 years in the NHL and scored 468 goals.
[sportscaster] ...LaFontaine scores! I don't believe it.
[Utley] He'd still be playing now except for one problem.
During his career Pat sustained at least six concussions.
[LaFontaine] You play with injuries. You play sick.
It's kind of a ritual of a hockey player that you don't complain.
You're there and play and overcome the adversity and the injuries
and just push through it.
[Utley] But then came a concussion that even Pat couldn't ignore.
I remember trying to make a drop pass to one of my teammates who was cutting behind me,
and just at the last second I looked up, and that was it.
It wasn't until later that I found out that the player who hit me was 6'6", 235,
and the only part of my body that was hit was my head.
I had lost my helmet, and my forehead had slapped off the ice.
[Utley] Sports are a major cause of brain injury from youth leagues up to the pros.
Studies show that every year 7 to 10 percent of all football players sustain a concussion.
Most of us think a concussion means being knocked unconscious,
but neurologists define it much more broadly
as any change in mental status resulting from trauma.
[Dr. Kelly] The players commonly will withhold information
about the symptoms they're having in order to get back at it.
I even know of one young high school football player who died
after having told a teammate, "Don't tell the coach that I have a headache
"and I feel like I'm going to throw up."
And in the second half of that football game he died.
[Utley] After his concussion, LaFontaine tried to soldier on.
He played six more games, but his symptoms soon got worse.
I couldn't sleep, I started getting migraine headaches
and I became very symptomatic.
I was wiped out physically, I was emotional, I was depressed...
and a total personality change.
How was this being manifested, felt in the family?
At one point I was reading a story to my daughters
and had trouble focusing in on the words and then skipping over words
and then having to look at my daughters and say,
"Daddy's just going to have to read this story another time."
[Utley] Over the next six months, his symptoms receded
and Pat yearned to play again.
Dr. Kelly told him bluntly of the risks, but then he cleared Pat to play.
[Kelly] When I examined him in some detail, I couldn't find anything I was worried about.
And as a physician, those are the individuals that I can say honestly to,
"I think it's okay to go back, but you understand you run a statistical risk
"of this coming back and maybe even being worse,
"even with a relatively lesser force."
And then it's up to the individual.
[sportscaster] Gretzky centers, LaFontaine scores!
[Utley] Pat played 67 more games for the New York Rangers.
But then in March 1998 he banged into a teammate and got hurt again.
It was a lesser collision this time. Pat wasn't even knocked out.
But the effects--headaches and chronic sleep problems--lingered for months.
This time Dr. Kelly told Pat it was time to quit.
[Kelly] One additional concussion could indeed tip him over the threshold
into a permanent condition of memory deficits and difficulty with concentration
and organizing his thinking.
And it's just not worth the risk because it has taken so long for him to recover
from relatively mild forces.
And I don't think that his brain can tolerate much more. [♪♪]
Dr. Kelly, that report was done a little while ago. How is Pat LaFontaine today?
[Kelly] He's actually fine.
He recovered fully again from that last concussion that was mentioned,
had nothing that could be found on detailed examination
or on scans.
He's now working in the civilian world,
the non-sports world, and doing very well.
[McMillon] Great. That's a good report.
Joining us now, Lesley LeMasurier is one of Dr. Kelly's patients.
By 18 years old she had already experienced four concussions.
One was the result of a car accident.
The others were caused by her sport of choice, Alpine ski racing.
Lesley, how did you get started in skiing?
Actually, my whole family learned to ski about the same time.
I was about six years old,
and it was just something different that we wanted to try.
We all enjoyed it, and we started skiing full time at Wintergreen Resort down in Virginia.
[McMillon] And so what did you like about it?
I just liked that it was different and challenging and fast.
It was all around very fun, and I just really enjoyed it.
Now to those of us who aren't skiers, ski racing seems so out of control.
Was fear a part of the process for you?
Not when I was younger.
When I was a little kid it was just so much fun and I loved it.
As I got older and started crashing more and more often,
there was a little fear involved.
But for the most part as a kid I just loved doing it.
[McMillon] How did you feel about the crashing part in the early days?
It was just part of the sport, really.
It was just something that came along with the sport.
You're going to fall if you're going to go at high speeds.
So I wasn't too scared of it.
When I started injuring myself, that's when there was a little more fear involved.
[McMillon] Tell us about your very first concussion.
My first concussion actually was in preseason training.
We played soccer a lot, and it actually came about during a soccer game.
I took a knee to the side of the head. It was a mild concussion.
I didn't lose consciousness, but I was very dazed and confused,
and I just had a headache.
So I was out for about a week, out of training.
Any other lasting effects from that one?
Not really. I had a headache, but they all sort of went away and I went back to training.
Okay. You experienced two more concussions.
What were doctors telling you and your parents?
Not a whole lot, actually.
My parents knew nothing about the brain or brain injury,
and they were actually in Virginia.
I was in Vermont going to school at the time, so they were kind of at a distance.
Doctors just said, "Be careful."
[McMillon] That was it. >>Skiing isn't a careful sport.
Right. Tell us, if you would, about the crash that you experienced
when you were training with the US Ski Team.
It was a fairly major crash.
I had actually been dealing with symptoms for about two years.
I had migraines and was having a hard time sleeping and trouble focusing.
Basically I just crashed so much I actually had a broken leg
and some torn ligaments in my other leg at that time when I entered the race,
but I was just pressured to basically compete and perform.
I was unsteady on my left side and lost my balance
and tore through three safety nets and barreled into the woods.
When I stood up, my helmet was in two pieces at my side.
[McMillon] My stars! You said you felt pressure.
You felt a lot of pressure from your teammates, pressure from yourself?
All around. There was pressure from every angle, really,
from coaches, teammates, family members.
Did you tell them that you weren't feeling well?
It was actually something I sort of protected.
I was a little bit in denial about the way that I was feeling.
You don't want to every day say that you feel sick
because you're going to start sounding like you're a complainer or making it up.
So I just kind of protected how bad I was actually feeling.
What was going on in your mind during all this time?
That's when the fear started to really creep in, I think,
because I couldn't explain what I was feeling to myself.
I had migraines, my heart rate was very high
and I was having trouble seeing, my eyes hurt, couldn't read without getting a migraine.
You said your heart rate was high. How did that manifest itself?
During training we would train with heart rate monitors on
when we were running or any type of workout on land.
We would wear heart rate monitors and work out in zones.
I basically couldn't stay in the zone.
I just was so much higher than all my teammates and was not recovering.
Let me ask you this. You wear a heart monitor to check your heart.
If the rate of your heartbeat goes up high, that's a problem, right?
[LeMasurier] Right. >>Did anybody else know that?
It was discussed, but they just thought because of the other injuries
that maybe I was just out of shape.
[McMillon] You were out of shape? Okay.
I'm going to move on past that one. [chuckles]
I think you said no blood, no break, keep going. And that's what you did.
Right. When the pressure is on, just basically there's no blood, no break,
I'm going to keep going, period. That's what athletes do.
They push through adversity and push through the pain and just try to perform.
[McMillon] And that's what you did. >>Correct. >>[McMillon] Did you win?
I didn't. I ended in MRI scans and in the hospital, basically.
All right. That's quite a story.
Dr. Kelly, what should we do as parents, as coaches,
if an athlete does suffer a brain injury like Lesley did?
Take it seriously,
certainly that kind of injury but even less clear injuries
like the ones that Lesley described earlier
because then I think that we have to acknowledge that those were concussions,
and maybe closer monitoring and so forth could have protected her
from additional problems down the road.
And so a parent or a coach needs to identify a healthcare professional
even if it's the primary care family doctor to start with
in order to identify the nature of the problem and get additional specialty help if necessary.
Do you find that some athletes like Lesley try to just ignore a brain injury,
just keep on going, work through it?
[Kelly] More commonly than not, yes.
And it's admirable in some ways that they are serious about their sport
and they want to get back at it, but it can be very harmful under these circumstances.
And so we really need to get them on board with the idea too, not to deny the symptoms.
In light of the fact that these symptoms can be long term and long ranging,
how do you change the mindset?
I've been trying this my whole career,
and it's been with limited success.
I really do think that the athletes like Pat and Lesley
are better at convincing other athletes than I have ever been.
They really do listen to each other under those circumstances.
[McMillon] Okay. Let me turn to Dr. Bhagwat.
I can imagine these feelings of not letting the team down.
I mean, nobody wants to do that.
But would it be significantly more intense on the battlefield?
How does this issue play out during a war?
I'm sure it would be.
You hear from the docs in theater about the troops who are injured in any way
wanting to return to be with their comrades.
But we are more aware of it now.
Commanders, the medics, even the servicemembers themselves
are aware of TBI.
There is an instrument in theater now that can be used called the MACE to identify TBI.
[McMillon] And that is? >>It's the Military Acute Concussion Evaluation.
People are trained on how to use it.
So any time there is an incident, whether it's an explosion or a car accident,
that can be brought out and the soldier can be assessed quickly.
All right. And that's key. >>[Bhagwat] It's key to do it soon.
Dr. Kelly, you treated Lesley. What's her prognosis?
And do her multiple concussions make her more vulnerable?
To the first question, we've talked about this in the last year or so
that the persistence of her symptoms and some subtle findings on examination
suggest that it would be unwise for her to return to that level of competitive skiing,
and we've talked openly about that before.
The risks are just too great.
But in terms of continued improvement and getting around things,
even just today I was learning that some things that I heard before she was struggling with
are now resolving.
And so continued improvement is part of the picture.
Okay, so she should not and will not ski competitively again.
[Kelly] Well? >>[LeMasurier] Correct.
[McMillon] Lesley says, "No question."
So how long do the cumulative effects last?
There's a greater risk earlier on after a concussion.
The sooner after a concussion there is another risk or exposure,
the more likely there's really going to be a repeated concussion
under those circumstances.
But we've been studying individuals in the sports community for years,
and after there have been at least two or sometimes three concussions
at some span, they have perhaps a decade or two decade or lifelong increased risk
of concussions from those earlier concussions.
We really don't understand why.
There may be some anatomical underlying change that's still there
that we simply can't see that makes the brain more vulnerable.
But we do know statistically the risk is greater if people have a history of concussions.
Okay. Lesley, let me come back to you for a moment.
Talk about that heart rate situation again.
What were your symptoms?
Basically if I was working out, it would just be so high for so long
and it wasn't recovering when I was just walking around trying to bring it down
in order to do the next exercise.
It led to exhaustion.
And then I was also suffering from trouble sleeping at night.
So it was just this cycle of I wasn't sleeping at night
and during the day my heart rate was incredibly high when I was standing.
And then I would just be so exhausted and have migraines.
I think you mentioned when we talked earlier about just walking across the campus.
When I would just walk, I would be out of breath and sweating,
and it was like I was out for a jog when I was basically just walking to class.
I would be embarrassed walking with my friends and here I am...
[McMillon] Breaking a sweat. >>Yeah, exactly.
Okay. Dr. Kelly, let's talk about the invisible symptoms.
Actually, that particular problem is something that I think physicians
haven't really paid attention to well enough over the years.
Lesley's condition I've seen in many athletes and other individuals.
It's called positional or postural orthostatic tachycardic syndrome.
[McMillon] Now, you want to translate that?
That means that the heart rate goes up when you stand.
And so the best way to test it is to have the individual lying down
for a few minutes so that the plumbing is horizontal, so to speak,
the heart isn't working very hard, and then you take the blood pressure and pulse
and then you ask the individual to stand up, wait a couple of minutes and do it again.
And under those circumstances, it was very clear that Lesley's pulse
went pathologically high.
It wasn't just the usual bump that we would get.
It was way high, 30 beats a minute more just by standing.
And that is one of those residual effects of a concussion
that I think without doing that kind of testing you just don't know about.
Dr. Bhagwat, how does the invisibility of mild TBI
impact the people that you see at Walter Reed?
At Walter Reed I think one of the goals that we have is to not have it invisible,
to make it as visible as possible.
We have a lot of information disseminated about TBI.
Almost every service or every service in the hospital and surrounding areas
will know about the possibility of TBI.
We screen very thoroughly every patient that comes through for a possibility of TBI.
Let's say a person has a wound that likely might not have caused a TBI.
If they report to their physician any symptoms that seem like they could be related,
they will still get thoroughly evaluated by us.
[McMillon] Okay. So you don't miss it at all if you can.
[Bhagwat] If we can. Sure. Absolutely.
All right. Thank you so much. I'd like to thank everyone.
And now I'd like to talk about treatment for concussion.
Dr. Kelly, Lesley came to you after multiple concussions.
What treatment did you recommend for her?
The commonest treatment that seems to be effective
is helping people become pain-free or reduce their pain
and have them sleep better.
It's uncommon, in my experience, for people with lingering symptoms from a concussion
to be sleeping normally.
Usually superimposed on that concussion effect is sleep deprivation
that protracts the course of recovery.
And so if we can help them sleep better in a predictable every night pattern
and get deep, restful, rejuvenating sleep, the concussion symptoms often resolve.
And so that was the first approach that we used.
[McMillon] How do you determine what the right course of treatment is
in the case of mild TBI?
[Kelly] It has to be individualized.
Every individual's version of their concussion and how it is they are affected
is a little bit different one from another.
And so even though there can be common themes and there are common symptoms
and even findings on exam, it's usually the case that somebody will benefit from one thing
a little bit more than another--the pain relief, the sleep issues,
there may be mood medications that are necessary
if it's a long time out from the injury and so forth.
So depending on that particular person's concussion effect,
we may tailor it differently.
How different is the quality of treatment across the country?
Actually, we're getting better at it nationwide in all areas little by little,
but we've still got a long way to go.
Even identifying concussions in sports or in the emergency departments
of our country, we have still a long way to go to get everybody on board
with just identifying a concussion and dealing with it in a serious way
rather than just dismissing it.
But I think much, much more information is out there now than had been
even ten years ago.
And the major physician organizations are really coming on board
with making sure their membership understands this.
Okay. Dr. Bhagwat, would you follow the same course of treatment
in the military population?
In general, yes. It's symptom driven.
Our servicemembers are often different from sports concussions
because they often have other traumatic injuries, whether they be amputations
or other internal injuries as well as psychological trauma
from post-traumatic stress disorder.
But again, the treatment is target driven, so we look for pain, try to control pain,
early education, intervention is very important,
teaching them what a concussion is, what the expected symptoms are
and the expectation for recovery down the road.
[McMillon] Okay. Are there any other unique challenges
dealing with mild TBI in the military?
I think significant is the overlay of pain and the other injuries
and the psychological issues that come through,
not just from the traumatic experiences but from being away for so long
and seeing all the things that they've seen.
So I think that complicates the picture at treatment.
Okay. And then the other wounds that they may be dealing with themselves.
Right. All the rehabilitation that takes place, especially for our amputee population.
There's a long rehab process that's involved as well,
a lot of pain, multiple surgeries.
All these things can help also perpetuate the symptoms that might have started
with a concussion, then get perpetuated from all these other injuries.
I see. Are there any special rehab protocols?
We have early intervention rehabilitation-wise.
We have a multidisciplinary team that tracks every TBI patient,
involves everyone from neurologists, physical therapists, occupational therapists,
speech therapists, psychologists, neuropsychologists,
a whole gamut of people are involved in treatment.
And we start that treatment early at Walter Reed itself,
and then we also work with the VAs, we work with community-based organizations,
so there's a thorough treatment blanket.
Okay. Dr. Kelly, what do we see in the general population?
Actually, the same basic picture in terms of symptoms,
although the symptoms that people under the circumstances in the military express
are very much as we just heard from Dr. Bhagwat.
The civilian population tends not to have as much post-traumatic stress disorder,
although it certainly can happen.
And so again, targeting the nature of the problems that the individual expresses
is key to this whole thing.
How do you determine whether or not someone has had a brain injury?
And then how would that affect treatment?
Again, we have to look at what actually happened to the individual at the time.
And it's absolutely critical to get as much information about that as you can.
So in my clinic, for instance, I'll try, if I can, to get the paramedics' information,
I'll try to get eyewitness reports,
I'll call individuals who actually have been living with that individual
or watching that person at work to look at the whole spectrum of change
in that individual over some span of time and try to get that information in
to determine whether a concussion occurred, how bad it was,
how much of that is what I need to address versus another professional
in some other area of medicine.
Okay. Dr. Bhagwat, what are researchers up to these days
that you think might help people who have mild TBI?
Looking at the symptom picture and what are ideal treatments for mild TBI,
I think something more important is just information dissemination,
which DVBIC actually does a lot of to get information out there,
teaching early on what the effects are and the expectations for recovery.
We're also looking at what is the symptom picture and what treatments work best
with which types of symptoms.
How can we best address the psychological effect of brain injury?
The same way with any other psychological effect.
Early intervention with psychotherapy, cognitive behavioral therapies can be very useful.
I think the more knowledge the patient has, the more power they have.
And Lesley, I know Dr. Kelly said it's probably a good thing
that you talk to your peers and folks that you participated with athletically.
Does that help?
Yes. I mean, it helps for me to talk about what's happened, but it also helps...
There's surprisingly still very little known about it among my family
and friends and teammates.
I'm just constantly teaching them more and more about TBI,
and it's just a constant learning process.
How did your parents and friends respond
once they figured out that there really was something wrong?
There were a lot of questions that were answered at that point
because they didn't know what was going on.
I basically changed completely as a person.
I was very angry and upset and frustrated and just always looked sick and felt sick.
And so a lot of those questions were answered, and they've been very supportive.
Wonderful. We've talked about mild TBIs, who is at risk and the causes.
We've discussed symptoms and treatment.
Now let's look to the future. How can we best prevent brain injury?
Here's more from Garrick Utley.
[Utley] For professional athletes and for the rest of us,
the biggest risk is having repeated concussions spaced closely together.
[Chestnut] As long as you're going to be slamming into each other,
you're going to get hurt.
We just need to make it so that when people have a concussion,
they don't go right back out and play again.
You can play for ten years, have five concussions and do fine.
If you play for ten years and have five concussions in one season,
you may never be the same.
Do you want to go on the swing set?
[Utley] Pat feels fine now, but Dr. Kelly says we need to take concussions
much more seriously.
[Kelly] And so we are advocating that at least some form of standardized mental status
or neuropsychological testing be performed in athletes
before their return to play.
[Utley] Prevention is still the best approach to brain injury.
[Chestnut] I'm not going to advocate that we not do sports with some element of danger.
However, those sports should be done as safely as possible.
If you're going to ride a bicycle, wear a helmet.
If you're going to ski hard, consider wearing a helmet.
Maybe someday if you're going to drive your automobile
we'll be considering wearing a helmet.
Okay. You've got to put your helmet on now.
[Utley] Helmets and seatbelts are essential, but they are no guarantee.
[Kelly] I played football and I wrestled and I recognize now
how unsafe those activities were that I engaged in.
And I simply would not allow my son to be subjected to those risks now.
[Utley] And Pat LaFontaine, whose career was cut short by six concussions,
would he let Daniel play professional hockey?
[LaFontaine] Well, if he continues to show the love of the game and enjoys it.
Seeing him and seeing his face and his competitiveness,
I have a feeling he's going to play sports.
And watching the enjoyment he gets out of just skating, he might be out there playing.
But if he chooses to play at that level, I don't think I'll have a problem.
What people don't really fully acknowledge is that the brain is truly the organ of the psyche
and that the things we think, the things we feel,
not just memory and concentration and all those sorts of cognitive functions
but the true core parts of us, who we are, emanates from the brain.
And injury to the brain changes who we are.
Dr. Kelly, some people would think it's pretty drastic
not to allow your child to play certain sports.
Why such a hard line stance?
In my case, my son made it easy.
He never did play the sports without helmets that I did as a kid.
On the other hand, he's a pilot and flies gliders and airplanes now,
so there is a different risk that he's taking on in a different way
with hopes of a military career.
And so there are things that I think all of us as parents need to do
to protect our kids in whatever realm we have control over and guide that.
And certainly helmets in high risk activities are a part of that picture.
Pat, in the piece that we just saw, said even though he knows what the risks are,
if his son wants to play, then he'd probably let him go ahead and play.
He and I have talked about that at some length.
I think if you really look at the risks an individual has
even at that elite level of sport, it's still the kind of thing that he would allow
under the circumstances for his child growing up,
taking more precautions than he ever did.
Let's talk about making sports safer.
That's really what this is all about, as far as I'm concerned.
And those of us who have done sports research in concussion
for our academic work are really interested mainly in making those sports safer,
not exposing problems, not causing trouble
but truly trying to make it safer for the athletes to play.
And so some of it has to do with helmet design.
A lot of it has to do with rule change and behavior change
and reducing risks and so forth, as Dr. Chestnut was talking about.
Are there any sports you feel should be outlawed?
I've, my whole career, gone along with the American Medical Association
and the American Academy of Neurology in calling for a ban on boxing.
But as you can see, we haven't been very successful in that either.
[McMillon] No. >>But for me, I don't consider that a sport in the same way
all the others are that we've talked about.
If the intention is to produce brain injury in somebody else
before he produces it in you, I don't consider that a sport.
Well, could you say what you mean? [Kelly chuckles]
Okay. In addition to wearing helmets, what are some of the other ways
that we could prevent mild trauma?
Again, rule changes in sports would be one important thing.
I think that what's happened in certain sports
is that there's actually a tendency toward more violent collisions,
and I've seen that over my academic life in hockey and football as just two examples.
And I think that if we can change some of that behavior,
we can reduce the incidence.
I think that if we can keep kids from taking unnecessary risks in life
in many other ways--and parents have a big obligation
and opportunity under those circumstances to protect their kids.
But they tell you the kid's got to live, he's got to play.
I think that we can actually lop off the extreme ends of that
and still give them plenty of room to play.
Okay. Let's talk about baseline testing in the general population.
What should we do?
Baseline testing in the general population may ultimately happen down the road.
I don't see any society now that we've been looking at other nations
that's actually had much effect in doing that.
We're able to do it in specific sports.
The pro ranks mostly do that now.
Many of the big colleges preseason test their athletes.
By baseline, what we're talking about is some battery of cognitive and other tests
that can be done before the individual is at risk of some kind of concussion.
And those are the kinds of things that our neuropsychologist colleagues
have driven forward.
And we've learned a lot because then we can use those same instruments
if a concussion does occur to track the recovery and guide that.
Okay. In addition to wearing helmets, what else do you think we need to do?
Again, I think largely it's behavior change.
It's convincing people to not take risks as we have been in our society.
Okay. Dr. Bhagwat, what are the challenges of conducting baseline testing in the military?
[Bhagwat] I think there are challenges in the military and the civilian world to do it.
If you just think of the numbers of how many servicemembers there are,
just the volume of testing that would have to be done to do it efficiently
yet do it well is difficult.
Also, you want to do baseline testing.
The goal is to really find them at their optimal level
so that if there is an injury, you can see a drop.
But getting this many people tested when they're at their optimal level,
if you have a person who maybe has the flu but is in line and gets tested,
then you're not going to get their optimal function.
[McMillon] Okay. What are some of the other prevention efforts
in which the military is involved right now?
[Bhagwat] I think the biggest prevention efforts for these would be the gear that they have,
the type of gear they wear, the type of helmet design that we were talking about
in sports as well, but in the military as well, that can absorb
maybe more of concussive forces.
[McMillon] And that's even changed a lot, hasn't it?
[Bhagwat] Oh, sure. Absolutely. Absolutely.
How successful do you think that a broad prevention campaign
has been in the country?
And then why is it so hard to get someone to wear a helmet or a seatbelt?
Dr. Kelly is smiling too. You can both answer. [all chuckle]
We've tried real hard to get just motorcycle helmets on the books as laws,
and in two of the states I've lived we've had very little success
in even getting that to happen.
And that seems a pretty logical thing to do,
and most states do have some type of helmet law.
But then there are people who object to that and don't want that kind of restriction.
They don't want to be told. They'll choose to do it and so forth.
So in our society where we have individual freedoms
that are so important to us, that debate has to go on,
and I think that it'll go on for years
because we really need to have more effective societal controls under the circumstances
that don't limit individual freedoms.
[McMillon] Dr. Bhagwat?
[Bhagwat] I was thinking also maybe there's a subset or a good set of the population
that maybe minimizes what the effects of a concussion might be
and just don't think it's that big a deal.
Just getting your bell rung once in a while may not have that much of an effect on your life.
They see it happen in sports.
They don't see the outcome sometimes to these athletes,
what happens with repeated concussions.
So I think until they've experienced it, maybe it's no big deal.
Now Lesley, you said that your helmet was kind of torn in two.
Imagine if you hadn't been wearing it.
[LeMasurier] I don't want to imagine that.
I was traveling about 70 miles per hour when that happened,
and I don't want to imagine what would have happened had I not been wearing the helmet.
Okay. I see that we have people in the audience who have some questions to ask.
Thank you so much. Go ahead with your question.
My question is for Lesley.
How would you recommend talking to a 20-year-old
who is not really interested in wearing their helmet on the slopes?
Basically, they don't want to be in my position ever
where I'm watching from the lodge and I'm not thinking--
I'm looking at 20-year-olds thinking, "Oh, they look nerdy in their helmets."
I'm thinking, "They look like they're about to go do what I want to do."
Even though I was going 80 miles an hour and was wearing a helmet,
injury will still occur if you're wearing a helmet.
So you should take that extra precaution.
If you're not wearing a helmet, just like I just said,
I wouldn't want to imagine what would have happened had I not been wearing the helmet.
It would have been much more severe.
So I would just say suck up your pride and wear the helmet.
Thanks so much. And I think we have another person who has a question.
Please go ahead.
Will heading a soccer ball give my child a concussion?
[McMillon] Dr. Kelly? Dr. Bhagwat?
[Kelly] The Institute of Medicine a few years back pulled a panel together,
and the research we were able to use at least several years back
indicated that heading the ball, as best we could tell,
if it's done right in the usual manner of propelling the ball in the other direction
by the plan, does not produce concussion.
And even just last year, the Swedes did a very nice study
looking at individuals heading the ball and then doing spinal fluid analysis,
spinal taps, looking for evidence of leaking from nerve cells
that they had already seen in boxers,
and they found none in the soccer players who were heading the ball.
So while it may not be a zero risk, we're not seeing evidence
of our kids' brains being injured by heading the ball in soccer.
[McMillon] All right. What about the neck?
The important issue is doing it right.
And so if we can tighten the neck muscles
and propel the ball so that the blow that the ball produces
is damped, if you will, physically by the mass of the whole body,
then things work out, we don't have a problem.
But if even inadvertently, especially a youngster's head is hit by a ball
that they don't see coming and the head moves,
concussion can occur under those circumstances.
So it's not as if soccer itself as a game with collisions and all
has a zero risk of concussion, but heading the ball, when done properly itself,
apparently does not.
[McMillon] Okay. Just another note on helmets.
If football players have to wear them, why shouldn't soccer players wear them?
There have been some attempts at making soccer helmets,
and those haven't really worked out very well
because what you're really looking for is something that would prevent the collision
kind of concussion in soccer from another person's knee
or heading each other because you're trying to head the ball.
And that kind of helmet interferes with heading the ball and playing the game and so forth,
and so it just hasn't worked out.
[McMillon] Okay. Let's take another question.
Does having a concussion make it more likely that someone will get Alzheimer's
or Parkinson's disease?
[McMillon] Dr. Bhagwat?
[Bhagwat] I think there's no data to show that one concussion in a lifetime
would increase the risk, but repeated concussions can increase your risk.
And of course we've also shown that having one concussion can increase your risk
for having another.
So repeated concussions can increase your risk,
especially if you have other loading for that risk anyway, like family members or...
[McMillon] Okay. Dr. Kelly?
The issue really is a combination of genetic predisposition,
as Dr. Bhagwat is mentioning, and the exposure to concussion.
There is some evidence even with one severe brain injury
and the predisposition genetically that those individuals are worse off,
much like an Alzheimer's picture down the road,
with just that combination.
But the interesting thing would be in boxing again
with people who have a lifetime, a career of multiple blows to the head.
And we know very well about what that looks like,
which is very similar to--a little different in terms of the cellular change,
but it's very similar to either Parkinson's or Alzheimer's,
a combination of those for many boxers who have had long professional careers.
[McMillon] It's kind of what we've seen in Muhammad Ali. >>Correct.
Right. Okay, let's take another question.
Hello. If I were to have a concussion now and recover fully,
what are the chances that I'll have problems down the road
with issues like memory or mood?
Your statistical risk of concussion is increased,
but long-term risk down the road we don't know.
It's not a very satisfying answer.
I can't say for sure that when you're my age you might have more problems
with memory and so forth.
We just don't have that kind of long-term data just yet
from a single concussion or even a couple.
But it looks like the individuals who have multiple concussions
or a much more severe injury are more likely to have those problems down the road,
and many, many individuals with a single concussion just fully recover
and don't have a lifelong problem.
[McMillon] Dr. Bhagwat, did you want to...
[Bhagwat] No. I would agree with that.
I think a single concussion, the likelihood is within a few days, weeks
you'll recover completely, and then we don't have the data to show
that down the road you're at increased risk.
[McMillon] Okay. Let's take another question. Thank you so much.
With senior citizens I'm wondering how you can tell the difference
between the natural consequences of aging and a possible concussion,
for example, memory loss.
Again, as Dr. Kelly had mentioned before, there has to be an injury
for there to be a concussion.
If the person has fallen or has been struck in the head for some reason,
then you can look at the effects of concussion.
And in terms of memory loss, if it was a concussion,
there would be other symptoms that would go along with it--
headaches, nausea, dizziness, maybe light sensitivity.
If none of those were there and there was no mechanism of injury,
the person didn't strike their head, then you would look at one of the other options
like a dementia or something.
[McMillon] All right.
Okay. One of the things that we talked about earlier,
of that spectrum of toddlers falling and hurting themselves
and seniors falling and hurting themselves,
how can we help the seniors in terms of not falling and then sustaining TBI?
That's actually a part of a program that's of major interest to geriatricians
and internists and neurologists, and there's actually a group
that's taken on that specifically to look at how do you prevent falls,
what are the causes of falls. Is it balance problems?
Is it that they're just not paying attention and it's really a cognitive problem
and they didn't see that there was a curb there, whatever.
Is it vision?
And so if in fact we can look at what the multiple organ system issues are
and in an individual's case address those,
once again tailoring to the individual, we can probably prevent at least some of that.
And so that's part of the concern right now for those physician organizations,
and there may be other groups involved as well.
[Bhagwat] That's right. I don't think there's a way to prevent 100 percent of falls
but looking at these factors and trying to reduce them.
[McMillon] Okay. Let's take another question.
Lesley, what's your recommendation for young athletes like you
who are forced to give up the sport they love at such an early age?
It was hard to give it up.
It was hard to accept that I wouldn't be skiing anymore.
It didn't happen overnight, but I found other things.
I was in school at the time, so I just focused on academics
and focused on finding other avenues, working out,
just doing mild activity and playing tennis and playing golf.
But it's been a process definitely,
and I would just recommend that they find other outlets, other things to do.
They're not going to probably ever have that thrill if they were thrill seekers,
but they can find other avenues.
[McMillon] Get a different thrill now. >>Right.
Okay. Let's take another question
and then we're going to be wrapping it up in just a moment. Thank you so much.
We hear a lot about brain health and brain exercises these days.
Would those be helpful to a person who has sustained a concussion?
[McMillon] Go ahead. >>[Bhagwat] I think they would be. That's part of the rehab process.
Speech language pathologists and occupational therapists
would use tools like that.
I don't think it would hurt the general population to do more of those things as well
with or without an injury.
[McMillon] All right. Dr. Kelly. >>It really is important.
The team approach then to the rehabilitation of those issues for a given individual
does include specialists that specifically use those various cognitive tasks,
homework and various things that actually do enhance the opportunities
for individuals to improve in those ways
that the specific cognitive problems they've had would indicate they need help.
[McMillon] All right. Thank you so much.
In closing, what I'd like to do is get a final thought from each of my terrific panelists.
Dr. Bhagwat, let me start with you.
I think one of the most important pieces is the education piece,
that the public get more awareness.
So I want to thank you for putting on this show.
Hopefully many people will watch it and learn more about concussion and not ignore it.
[McMillon] All right. Lesley.
Going off that, I ignored it and tried to protect the symptoms
and not talk about them, and I ended up just injuring myself so much more
and putting myself at greater risk for worse injuries or possibly even death.
And so I hope that if people are feeling these symptoms--athletes, anybody--
that they do seek help if they have had a brain injury,
that these can be because of the brain.
It's not just you, it's not your attitude, it's not that you're bringing this upon yourself.
You may have something wrong with your brain like I did.
[McMillon] All right. Dr. Kelly.
I'd like to emphasize, as you brought up in this show too,
the importance of prevention strategies.
Our very best treatment for brain injury is preventing it in the first place.
[McMillon] All right. You guys have been a terrific panel,
and I want to thank again Dr. Bhagwat and Dr. Kelly,
and also many thanks to Lesley LeMasurier for sharing her story.
I'm Doris McMillon. Thank you so much for watching us on BrainLine.org
[applause] [♪upbeat music♪]
[female announcer] BrainLine is funded by the Defense and Veterans Brain Injury Center,
the primary operational TBI component of the Defense Centers of Excellence,
through the Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine.