Page Utilities


I Wanted My Brain Back Sherri Dalphonse, Washingtonian Magazine (page 2 of 6) Page 2 of 6

Kathy Rabin, a friend from Yale, knew Anne was having problems—she had Anne call her every day to check in. But she didn’t realize the extent of the difficulties until Anne visited her in Boston. Kathy went out and left her dog in the yard, asking Anne to let the dog in. Hours later, when Kathy returned, the yellow Lab was outside the back door.

When Kathy visited Anne, who lived alone, she discovered notes stuck all over Anne’s apartment. One affixed to the front door said take keys, wallet, call kathy.

Anne couldn’t remember anything new unless she wrote it down. “That summer’s a bit of a blur,” she says.

Her short-term memory was so bad, she says, “I could hide my own Easter eggs.”

She slept a lot, sometimes 18 hours at a time. One activity a day—going to a doctor’s appointment or to a friend’s—was all she had energy for.

Prior to the accident, Anne was energetic, fun to be with, always making friends.

Lawrence Pratt, a former colleague at the Environmental Law Institute, recalls a time when Anne gave a cranky parking attendant a cake. “She told him, ‘You are always mean to me. I don’t know what I did, but I baked you a cake to see if I could fix whatever it is.’ The man gave her a hug and wept.”

Some friends began to wonder if Anne, who had lived and worked at a fast pace, was having a nervous breakdown. “Our thought was, ‘What can we do to get Anne to snap out of this?’ ” Pratt says.

Friends didn’t connect her behavior to the accident. “We did not have the cues that movies train us to look for,” he says. “No amnesia, no head bandage.

“It was terrifying to see a person with that much talent and potential suffer from something so invisible.”

Six Months Out: A Lot of Help From Her Friends

In brain injury, the frontal lobes sustain most of the damage, says the Brain Injury Association’s Gregory O’Shanick.

The frontal lobes help us plan and follow through, part of executive functioning. They control concentration and problem-solving.

O’Shanick explains the damage using a computer analogy. “With the injury, somebody changed her processor from a Pentium 4 to a Pentium 1, and somebody reduced her RAM,” he says. “It takes her longer to process than it used to.”

Anne’s mother had died, and her father and siblings lived far away, so she relied on friends like Michael and Kathy. They talked her through phone calls she had to make to doctors and insurers. They rescued her when she locked herself out of the house or took the wrong bus. After she left a stove burner on, Michael bought her a toaster oven and a rice cooker—things that shut themselves off.

Anne tried to work, putting in a few hours a week. Interns had to read her her mail. She couldn’t use a computer. Depression crept in. “I wanted my brain back,” she says.

For months, Anne had undergone tests, including magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), an electroencephalogram (EEG), and computed tomography (CT scan). Injury to the brain’s axons usually does not show up on CT scans or MRIs. Doctors told her the test results were fine.

“Mine is the best-studied brain in Washington,” she says. Still, she says, “I couldn’t do things, and no one could tell me why.”

Accurate diagnosis is one of the difficulties in mild brain injury. “Individuals have been misdiagnosed with having depression or as malingerers,” says O’Shanick.

“Mild-injury issues are so different,” Anne says. “A lot revolves around the fact that others cannot see the injury and around trying to get back to work and life when you cannot get appropriate care.” She eventually stopped using her disabled bus pass because drivers questioned why she had one.

During appointments, doctors didn’t always notice her deficits. She wasn’t selfaware enough to see them.

“I didn’t know enough to say, ‘I can’t do this and I can’t do that,’ ” says Anne. “Your brain’s not working, so you can’t process that your brain’s not working. You have a brain injury, you think the doctor can see it.”

Money became an issue. Short-term disability had run out, and Anne’s health insurer denied her long-term disability until it knew what was wrong. She went through more tests.

Even Anne began to wonder: Was it psychological? “It’s a period where you’re vulnerable because you’re not sure what’s wrong,” she says.

The results of neuropsychological tests done by her doctors were consistent with brain injury. Still, she’d received little treatment.

“A lot of people get lost in the system,” says Annandale neuropsychologist Alec Lebedun. “People can wander around for years until they find the right person.”

One problem is a lack of programs and therapists trained to work with mild head injuries, says Dr. Yehuda Ben-Yishay, founder of a brain-injury treatment program at New York University Medical Center. Another is that insurers sometimes won’t pay for cognitive rehabilitation or pay for a limited amount.

In recent decades, everything from air bags to advances in emergency medicine have meant that people in car accidents and other traumas are more likely to survive their injuries—and more likely to need long-term services.

Thirty years ago, says Susan Connors of the Brain Injury Association of America, half of those who sustained head injuries in a car crash died at the scene. Today, less than a quarter do.

The thing Anne needed to navigate the maze of medicine and insurance—her brain—was what was impaired.

On her own, Anne had been seeing a chiropractor for headaches and neck pain. The chiropractor, Philip Shambaugh, recommended she see a developmental optometrist, Amiel Francke, after Anne complained that she couldn’t read.

Twice a week, she attended small-group sessions to practice eye exercises such as following her thumb. The idea of vision therapy is to retrain the eyes to move correctly with the brain. The signals coming into Anne’s brain were so distorted, life was like watching a foreign movie in which the English dubbing is out of sync—but you don’t know it’s out of sync.

   | 2 | | | |   

From the Washingtonian Magazine. Reprinted with permission. Third-party use restricted. www.washingtonian.com.

 Comments [5]

I read this article and felt the pain and frustration again that I felt for the first 4 years after my "mild" tbi and then sustaining a 2nd one within 2 years of the first. I dealt with so many specialists that when stymied for an answer would turn it back on me as being a malingerer and hypochondriac. For my own peace of mind I eventually paid out of pocket for a neuropsych evaluation and finally got answers to so many questions I had. My mri's, ct scans, xrays, etc... never could show the damage, but the neuropsych eval did. What a blessing to finally "see" the areas that were damaged and try to get help. In my area there was not much help, but through trial and error I have retrained parts of my brain. This unfortunately is typical for the many that have brain trauma and no set plan or group of medical people that are prepared to help. I am sad it has taken so many brain injuries from the war to bring this to public attention, yet glad that it has indeed become better known.

Jan 8th, 2011 11:51pm

I am caregiver to my brother Kenneth, he was hit by a drunk driver in 1980. Kenny sustained severe TBI and was cared for by our mother for over twenty years, at which time she was diagnosed with ALZ. Your artical gave me a pin whole look into what my brother has been going through for over thirty years. He is doing very well and I am pleased to see that TBI is begining to come to the for front in society. It still has a long way to go. Thank you for your story and I wish the best for all those with TBI.

Jun 24th, 2010 9:30pm

This is me. But I fought it for over 6 years and was wife, mother of 4 kids and teacher of 125 8th graders everyday. Determined to be normal ~ afterall I looked normal. I fought the neuropsych eval that suggested disability. C'mon I have a Masters plus, I am not a mooron. My anxiety consumed me and I was like I had mania until 2 years ago and I began to drown. I couldn't remember what I was teaching and "my kids names". I came home and slept and I wasn't a mother just an anxious screaming hormonal sounding woman. I kept pushing my family doc ~ this isn't me, something is wrong. There was no followup once I left the rehab unit I spent 3 weeks in except to see the neurosurgeon for the c-2 fracture and eye doctor after eye doctor for a 4thoptic nerve palsy. When the neurosurgeon said the break was healed he said I could resume working and I was okay! I am not okay and that was in 2000. My brain and my body aren't mind and if this is what I have been given, I need some help accepting this and learning to live with what I have. I feel like a failure.

Dec 30th, 2009 10:53pm

What a story...and so familiar. I was an attorney practicing law, arguing cases, able to recall facts on a moments notice. I am now a legal secretary, earning 1/3 of what I used to, and so frustrated by the fact that I'm not what I once was and that maybe I won't ever be. Your story gave me hope that with the right effort, we can get back on track. Having some sort of support would be very helpful.

Sep 10th, 2009 7:27pm

Thank you for sharing this story. My heart goes out to you. I my self struggle with post traumatic stress disorder, so I guess I can empathize with you when it comes to daily struggles. Just now I am learning about traumatic brain injury and what it's all about. I am in the middle of getting my degree in psychiatric nursing and psychology. I would love to be part of the group that deals with such amazing people like you. Again, thank you for not giving up.

Aug 21st, 2009 10:45pm

Related Content